Data studies

How accurate is a Fear & Greed index? We tested ours on Bitcoin

Since January 2024 the Sentalysis Fear & Greed gauge marked seven extremes on its chart, and after each one Bitcoin went on to move hard the other way: +23% to +89% after Extreme Fear, −16% to −31% after Extreme Greed. It read the crowd well over three months, rarely on the day, and missed only once.

BTC / USDT · 1D · since January 20247 extremes Extreme Fear Extreme Greed
$40k$60k$80k$100k$120k−21%+89%−16%+61%−31%+23%+32%F&GJan 2024Jul 2024Jan 2025Jul 2025Jan 2026Jul 2026
Each dot is the first day of an extreme reading; its label is Bitcoin's largest move the other way within four months. The strip below is the gauge, day by day, in its band colors.
Live · Crypto Fear & Greed today28 · Fear−3 this weekSee today's reading
In this guide

Key takeaways

  1. Seven of the eight extremes since January 2024 were followed within four months by a large move against the crowd: +23% to +89% after fear, −16% to −31% after greed.
  2. After fear, patience paid: Bitcoin was higher 90 days later on 85% of Fear days and 68% of Extreme Fear days, against 54% of all days.
  3. After greed, it rarely was: higher on 8% of Greed days and 12% of Extreme Greed days.
  4. Extremes come early: in five of the seven, price first went more than 5% further the crowd's way before it turned.

The seven extremes

We count an extreme from the first day the gauge reads 25 or below (Extreme Fear) or 75 or above (Extreme Greed) after a month without one. Each one, where Bitcoin turned, and its largest move the other way within four months:

  1. Extreme Greed

    Gauge at 77, Bitcoin at $68,124. The top came 6 days later, 8% higher.

    −21%by 5 Jul 2024
  2. Extreme Fear

    Gauge at 22, Bitcoin at $55,134. The low came 30 days later, 5% lower.

    +89%by 5 Dec 2024
  3. Extreme Greed

    Gauge at 79, Bitcoin at $91,032. The top came 32 days later, 19% higher.

    −16%by 11 Mar 2025
  4. Extreme Fear

    Gauge at 24, Bitcoin at $76,322. The low came the next day, 2% lower.

    +61%by 14 Jul 2025
  5. Extreme Greed

    Gauge at 79, Bitcoin at $116,462. The top came 58 days later, 8% higher.

    −31%by 21 Nov 2025
  6. Extreme Fear

    Gauge at 25, Bitcoin at $67,485. The low came 2 days later, 7% lower.

    +23%by 6 May 2026
  7. Extreme Fear

    Gauge at 25, Bitcoin at $66,329. The low came 16 days later, 13% lower.

    +32%by 21 Sep 2026

What usually came next

Extremes are rare, so here is every day instead: for each band, how often Bitcoin closed higher 90 days later. The dashed line is the share for all days, whatever the gauge read.

Bitcoin higher 90 days laterBy gauge band
Extreme Fear68%+25% typical
Fear85%+23% typical
Neutral or Mixed53%+1% typical
Greed8%−12% typical
Extreme Greed12%−14% typical
Every day from 1 January 2024 to 16 August 2026, the last day with a 90-day result. Below each share, the median move.

The fear side beat the baseline by a wide margin and the greed side fell far short of it. The middle of the gauge said almost nothing, which is what a mood reading should do on an ordinary day.

Would it have worked on the day?

Today's reading only uses what is known today. Past days are different: the gauge compares every day with its whole history, so when a new extreme arrives, older readings can shift. That is deliberate. It lets a record panic show as a record, instead of every new extreme looking like the biggest ever.

Because the past can shift, we reran the study using only what was known each day. It held: Bitcoin was higher 90 days later after 74% of Extreme Fear days and 14% of Extreme Greed days. It adds one miss: on 26 January 2026, Extreme Fear came before a further 32% fall. That's one in eight extremes since 2024.

How to read the next extreme

  1. Treat it as an alarm, not a trigger

    An extreme says the crowd is stretched, not when the turn comes. Here the turns came between 1 and 58 days after the extreme began.

  2. Let price confirm

    Wait for price to stop going the crowd's way. The turning-points study shows attention spiking on the day of the low itself.

  3. Have it watched for you

    The gauge is free on every account and live here. Plus sends an alert when attention crosses your level; Pro builds a Fear & Greed of your own.

Method and limits

  • Data: the Sentalysis Crypto Fear & Greed gauge, daily, beside Binance BTC/USDT daily candles from 1 January 2024 to 14 November 2026. Ninety-day results run to 16 August 2026.
  • An extreme: counted from the first day at 25 or below, or 75 or above, after 30 days without that extreme. Its largest move is the highest high (after fear) or lowest low (after greed) of the next 120 days.
  • Limits: under three years and one market cycle; seven signals is a small sample; neighbouring days overlap, so the band shares are not independent trials; no fees or slippage. Past behavior does not promise future results.

FAQ

Questions and answers

Read the guides

How accurate is the Fear and Greed Index?

Judged on the Sentalysis gauge since January 2024: as a three-month contrarian read, well. Bitcoin was higher 90 days after 68% of Extreme Fear days but only 12% of Extreme Greed days, against 54% of all days. As a timer it is weak: turns came from 1 to 58 days after an extreme began.

Is the Fear and Greed Index a contrarian indicator?

It is most useful read that way: extreme fear has tended to come near lows and extreme greed near highs. Seven of the eight extremes since 2024 were followed within four months by a move the other way (+23% to +89% after fear, −16% to −31% after greed), though price often went further the crowd's way first.

Should I buy when the index shows extreme fear?

Sentalysis gives research data, not advice. In this period Extreme Fear was usually followed by higher prices three months later, and only one extreme in eight failed: on 26 January 2026, Extreme Fear came before a further 32% fall. Treat an extreme as a reason to look closer, not as an order.

How often does the gauge reach an extreme?

Eight times since January 2024 by the definition here, a first day at 25 or below or 75 or above after a month without it: five fear extremes and three greed extremes. That is about one every four months.

Put the guide to work on real data

Sentalysis charts crypto prices beside the Attention Interest Oscillator, maps social discussion with HiveMind, and lets you build indexes and alerts of your own.

Free plan: one keyword, daily data, two years of history. No card required.

Sentalysis is an analytics and research tool. Nothing on this page is financial, investment or trading advice, a trading signal or a price prediction, and similar timing between attention and price does not establish cause. Sentalysis does not execute trades or connect to wallets or exchanges. Read the research-use notice.